Electronic Drums vs. Acoustic Drums

a drummers back wearing checkered shirt

The beauty of a drum set is that it can be tailored to a beginner drummer, an amateur drummer, and a professional drummer’s need.

A beginner drummer may not need all the pieces to learn how to play, and they are more cautious with their purchase on a drum kit because they don’t want to spend a lot of money for something that they aren’t good at playing. 

On the other hand, a professional drummer will know exactly how many pieces they would need and most likely he/she will require high-end equipment. Whether you are a beginner drummer or professional drummer, both electronic and acoustic drum sets are accessible for their needs.

There is a dynamic range of pricing for the drum sets, but the main consideration boils down to practicality and playability. Let’s find out what set is right for you.

I am not trying to offend anyone here, but what type of house do you live in? Here is why I am asking this question.

Even in an average house, the sound can move outside and into your neighbor’s house. If your neighbor is okay that you are playing the drum in the evening, you have no problem. But most of the time many neighbors will not be okay that you are banging on the drum, while they have to wake up early the next day and go to work. By all means, the sound levels can be an issue for someone who lives in an apartment, a townhouse, a condo, and a house close to their neighbors. 

If this is you, you may want to consider purchasing an electronic drum set. You can play using headphones or at lower volumes through an amplifier and not disturb anyone around you. 

Please note that it is not entirely true that the electronic drums make no sound at all. When you are hitting the pads with the sticks, plastic cymbals, and the bass pad using the bass drum beater can make consistent and repetitive sounds that can bother your household members.

Another factor to consider before you choose your next drum is to make sure that you have enough space for the drum set. There are some smaller sized electronic drum sets that take up less space than the acoustic drum sets; you would need a floor space of 5 to 7 sq. ft to fit your drum set and the drum throne.

Anyone who tries to play the drum in a confined space or too close to the drum will be very annoyed and would have an actual negative impact on playing skills. Let’s think about this for a second; if you are too close to the drum, your body posture and technique will be poor. Just like driving or cooking, you’ll need to have your fundamental skills: sitting with a proper posture and practicing basic techniques, to improve your skills.

It’s always a great way to practice your fundamentals regularly to make sure that you are improving useful technique and good playing habits. As you can see, you won’t be able to have these fundamentals if you are sitting too close to the drum set.

Let’s discuss your budget. The electronic drum set has a various range of prices to choose from. You can read about how to select the best electronic drums. The ones we reviewed are fantastic drum sets, and you’ll be able to find the one that suits your drum needs and budget. It is worth mentioning that some electronic drum sets’ drum pads are often undersized. 

Typically, the average diameter of these drum pads being 8 inches. As these pads are put on a drum rack system, the net result in that the drums are fitted compact size together. You have saved a tiny amount of space, but we are concerned that your position may be cramped and that it affects your posture. We are finding that many manufacturers are now making full-sized drum shells and we think this is the right move.

Most acoustic drum set comes as a package. It includes drums, stands, pedals, and cymbals and they can start at $500 price range. There are cheaper ones out there and more significantly expensive drums than that. If you are interested in the kid’s acoustic drum sets, you can check out this article.

The most significant difference is the overall difference in feel. The real drum head is made out of different material than the electronic drum pads that are made from rubber, plastic, or mesh. Many electronic drum manufacturers are trying to make the similar type of materials as the acoustic ones nowadays.

One of the benefits for any drummer who is using the electronic drum pads is that it lets you get away with certain things that acoustic drums will not. If there is any playing part that you’re working on the drumming techniques, then acoustic drums will reveal those shortcomings, the electronic drum set mesh heads can let you cover up all the mistakes.

Many drummers who play and practice consistently on electronic drums can often have a tough time moving on to acoustic drums. Those will need to spend a good time playing in the acoustic drum set because the articulation of the cymbals, the response of the drums and the different dynamic approach are very different.

For example, when you are hitting a bass drum beater into a kick drum head on the acoustic drum, you get to hear the vibration and the air pushing out of the drum. You get to listen to the low, loud thumping sound that you can only get from a real bass drum. This, of course, is one of the reasons why some people prefer playing the acoustic drum. You get that thrilling and exciting feeling as you play.

There are strong advocates of the acoustic drum because they say that nothing beats the conquering feeling of letting loose on what many refer to as “real drums.” However, many people prefer electronic drums because it provides an excellent alternative option in situations where an acoustic set may be suitable for them.

About the author


Click here to add a comment

Leave a comment: